Is a PDF an e-invoice? The answer by country, and which part counts
A plain PDF is not a structured e-invoice. A hybrid invoice such as Factur-X or ZUGFeRD can be one: it is a PDF with the invoice data embedded as XML, and software reads that XML without retyping. At the same time, under the EU VAT Directive a PDF sent by email is still an electronic invoice today, as long as your customer accepts it. That is why the answer depends on the country. In Belgium a PDF has not been enough between Belgian businesses since 1 January 2026. In France the same has applied to large companies and intermediate-sized enterprises (ETIs) since 1 September 2026. In Germany a PDF between German businesses is still allowed until the end of 2026, for smaller businesses until the end of 2027. In the Netherlands a PDF is fine, except for central government. Below is what counts in each country, with the law or the tax authority as the source. As of 20 October 2026.
The answer by country
| Country | Plain PDF | PDF with XML (Factur-X, ZUGFeRD) | From when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Netherlands | Allowed if your customer accepts it. Central government sends it back. | Allowed. Central government asks for SI-UBL 2.0 or Peppol BIS 3.0. | A business-to-business obligation is planned for 1 July 2030 |
| Belgium | No longer enough between VAT-registered businesses established in Belgium. Allowed for consumers. | No Belgian source mentions Factur-X or ZUGFeRD. The default is Peppol BIS over Peppol; another format under the European standard only if both parties agree, and even then you must be able to send and receive Peppol BIS. | 1 January 2026 |
| Germany | A “sonstige Rechnung”. Between German businesses with consent until the end of 2026, with at most 800,000 euros in turnover until the end of 2027. | Counts as an E-Rechnung from ZUGFeRD 2.0.1, except in the MINIMUM and BASIC WL profiles. | Receiving since 1 January 2025, issuing from 2027 and 2028 |
| France | Not a “facture électronique” under the reform. Allowed for consumers and foreign customers, and for SMEs until 1 September 2027. | Counts with an XML in the EN 16931 or EXTENDED-CTC-FR profile, through a plateforme agréée. | Large companies and ETIs since 1 September 2026, SMEs from 1 September 2027 |
| Whole EU, trade between member states | No longer enough from then. | Counts if all the data to be reported is in the XML. | 1 July 2030 |
Two meanings of “electronic invoice”
Ask whether a PDF is an e-invoice and the answer is usually “no”. That is only half right. EU law has two definitions side by side.
- Under the VAT Directive, a PDF is an electronic invoice. The VAT Directive calls an invoice electronic if it “has been issued and received in any electronic format” (Article 217). That definition says nothing about structure. A PDF sent by email therefore counts, as long as the recipient accepts it (Article 232). This definition applies until 30 June 2030.
- For the European standard, a PDF is not. Directive 2014/55/EU on electronic invoicing in public procurement requires “a structured electronic format which allows for its automatic and electronic processing”. It adds: “A mere image file should not be considered to be an electronic invoice for the purpose of this Directive.” The countries with an obligation follow this narrower line.
- From 1 July 2030 the narrower meaning becomes the rule. ViDA, Directive (EU) 2025/516, then replaces the VAT definition with a structured one. From that date a PDF is no longer an electronic invoice, although countries may keep allowing it for some invoices.
You can see the distinction in the words. Belgium speaks of an “ordinary” and a “structured” electronic invoice. Germany speaks of a “sonstige Rechnung” and an “E-Rechnung”, and already dropped the broad meaning on 1 January 2025: since then a PDF has not been an electronic invoice there. In France, under the general invoicing rules, a PDF with a reliable audit trail is a “facture électronique”, but under the reform it is not. In the Netherlands, the VAT Act defines the electronic invoice without a structure requirement (Article 35d), the Public Procurement Act with one.
Official source: the VAT Directive and Directive 2014/55/EU.
When a PDF with XML is an e-invoice
A hybrid invoice is one PDF/A-3 file with two parts: the PDF you read, and an XML file inside it with the invoice data in a fixed structure. In their current versions, Factur-X 1.09 and ZUGFeRD 2.5, Factur-X and ZUGFeRD are the same format under two names. Whether such a file is an e-invoice depends on four things.
- The XML has to be complete. The profile sets how much data it holds. MINIMUM is never enough. In Germany ZUGFeRD counts from version 2.0.1, except the MINIMUM and BASIC WL profiles. In France the law names the EN 16931 and EXTENDED-CTC-FR profiles; the French standard XP Z12-012 still allows BASIC WL until 1 September 2027, but that exception is not in the legal text.
- The XML has to be valid. In Germany an XML with a format error is not an E-Rechnung for tax purposes, but a sonstige Rechnung. An error against a business rule does not turn it into a sonstige Rechnung.
- The PDF and the XML have to say the same thing. In Germany the XML is authoritative. If they differ, the XML prevails, and a deviating PDF can count as a second invoice on which you may also owe the VAT. Small technical differences, such as rounding, do not count. Input VAT can only be deducted from the XML. In France the law and the official texts do not say which part prevails; the French standard requires the PDF to show all the data in the XML.
- The channel has to fit. In Germany the channel is free: a ZUGFeRD sent by email is an E-Rechnung. In France an e-invoice goes through a plateforme agréée. In Belgium the default is Peppol BIS over the Peppol network.
A PDF/A-3 on its own is not an e-invoice yet. PDF/A-3 is the container that may carry an XML attachment. Without a valid XML inside, it stays a PDF. Read what PDF/A-3 is, or put Factur-X, ZUGFeRD and UBL side by side.
Official source: Federal Ministry of Finance, BMF letter of 15 October 2025.
A PDF in an e-invoice is not an e-invoice in a PDF
With Factur-X the XML sits inside the PDF. With Peppol BIS it is the other way round: the invoice is an XML message, and a PDF may travel inside it as an attachment. That PDF is then an attachment, not the invoice.
- Belgium says so explicitly: you may voluntarily send a PDF alongside the structured invoice, but the structured electronic invoice is the only invoice that is legally required. An attachment belongs in the same channel as the invoice, not in a separate email.
- Germany requires all mandatory data to be in the structured part. A PDF attachment may only add to it, for example with a timesheet.
- Some customers ask for it. Under its contract annex, UWV, the Dutch employee insurance agency, wants the PDF version as an attachment in the e-invoice; see e-invoicing to the Dutch government.
Official source: Peppol BIS Billing 3.0.
A scan or photo of an invoice
A scanned or photographed invoice is nowhere a structured e-invoice. Germany explicitly calls an image file a sonstige Rechnung. France says that a “facture numérisée” sent by email is not a facture électronique. Scanning is a way to keep records, though: in the Netherlands you may scan paper invoices and throw away the original, as long as the scan is accurate and complete and the authenticity features are stored with it.
Netherlands: a PDF is fine, except for central government
- VAT. A PDF sent by email is an electronic invoice (Article 35d of the VAT Act), as long as your customer accepts electronic invoicing (Article 35b). That acceptance may be tacit: a customer who processes and pays the invoice without comment has accepted it.
- Authenticity and storage. You safeguard the authenticity of origin, the integrity of the content and the legibility until the end of the retention period, and you choose how. You keep a digital invoice digitally; printing it and keeping only the paper is not allowed.
- Central government. Suppliers to the central government invoice only electronically with an e-invoice, as the purchasing terms put it. A PDF by email is not an e-invoice there and is sent back. Read e-invoicing to the Dutch government.
- From 2030. The government plans to make e-invoicing between businesses mandatory from 1 July 2030, with digital reporting from 1 July 2031. Businesses under the small business scheme (KOR) are left out under the plan. The bill has yet to be submitted.
Official source: VAT Act 1968, Article 35d.
Belgium: no more PDFs between Belgian businesses
Since 1 January 2026, a VAT-registered business established in Belgium issues a structured electronic invoice to a VAT-registered customer that is also established in Belgium. A PDF is still an electronic invoice in Belgium, the “ordinary” kind, but it is no longer enough here. The government says that sending a PDF invoice by email or through a platform will no longer suffice. The default is Peppol BIS over the Peppol network.
- What is still allowed. A PDF to consumers, if the customer agrees. A PDF as a voluntary extra copy next to the structured invoice. And an ordinary invoice, including a PDF, if your customer cannot technically receive; it is then legally valid.
- Who is out of scope. Businesses not established in Belgium, even with a Belgian VAT number. Flat-rate taxpayers do not have to issue, but must be able to receive. Small businesses under the exemption scheme are in principle in scope.
- Fines. Anyone unable to issue and receive risks 1,500 euros, 3,000 euros for a second offence and 5,000 euros after that. The tolerance period of the first quarter of 2026 is over.
- For your customer. For VAT deduction they in principle need a structured invoice. If the substantive conditions are met, the Federal Public Service Finance does not refuse the deduction.
Read the Belgian rules at a glance.
Official source: efactuur.belgium.be.
Germany: a PDF is a “sonstige Rechnung”
Since 1 January 2025, an E-Rechnung in Germany is only an invoice in a structured format. The Federal Ministry of Finance puts it this way: “Beispielsweise ein einfaches PDF-Dokument fällt dann nicht mehr unter diese Definition, da es kein strukturiertes Format hat.” Since then a PDF has been a “sonstige Rechnung”, just like paper.
- Transition. Until 31 December 2026 every German business may still send a PDF, with the recipient’s consent. That consent may be tacit. For transactions in 2027 this is allowed until the end of 2027 only if the issuer had at most 800,000 euros in turnover the year before. After that, the E-Rechnung is the rule between German businesses.
- Receiving. Every German business has had to be able to receive an E-Rechnung since 1 January 2025. An email inbox is enough.
- Always out of scope. Invoices to consumers, invoices up to 250 euros including VAT and invoices from Kleinunternehmer. The obligation also applies only if both the supplier and the customer are established in Germany.
- The risk. A PDF where an E-Rechnung was required does not lead to a fine, according to the Federal Ministry of Finance. The risk lies with your customer: their input VAT deduction is then in principle open to challenge.
Read how to create an XRechnung, or the German rules at a glance.
Official source: Federal Ministry of Finance, FAQ E-Rechnung.
France: under the reform a PDF is not a “facture électronique”
The French tax authority says it in so many words: a PDF sent by email, scanned or produced by an office program, “n’est pas une facture électronique”.
- Who has to. Since 1 September 2026 every French VAT-registered business must be able to receive e-invoices, through a plateforme agréée. Large companies, ETIs and VAT groups have also been issuing them since then. SMEs and micro-businesses follow on 1 September 2027.
- Which formats. UBL, CII or Factur-X, with an XML in the EN 16931 or EXTENDED-CTC-FR profile.
- Where a PDF is still allowed. For consumers and foreign customers; the data of those invoices does go to the tax authority through e-reporting. And for SMEs until their own date, 1 September 2027.
- Fine. 50 euros per invoice not issued electronically, up to 15,000 euros a year. The minister has promised that no penalties will be imposed before the end of 2026.
Read the French rules at a glance.
Official source: impots.gouv.fr.
Poland, Italy and Spain
- Poland. Invoices have gone through KSeF since February and April 2026, as XML in the FA(3) structure. A PDF is not the invoice there. A visualisation with a QR code may serve outside KSeF, for example for a foreign customer. A PDF is allowed for consumers. Businesses invoicing at most 10,000 zloty a month (including VAT) may still use paper or PDF until the end of 2026.
- Italy. Invoices between parties established in Italy have gone through the SdI since 2019, as XML. An invoice outside the SdI counts as not issued. A PDF is only a copy, for example for a consumer.
- Spain. A PDF with the customer’s consent still counts. The structured obligation between businesses starts on 6 October 2027 for turnover above 8 million euros, and on 6 October 2028 for everyone else.
Read e-invoicing mandates by country.
From 1 July 2030: the narrower meaning becomes the rule
- New definition. An electronic invoice is then an invoice that, at least for the data to be reported, has been issued, transmitted and received in a structured format.
- Trade between member states. For invoices to businesses in another member state, the e-invoice under EN 16931 becomes mandatory, with digital reporting. A PDF is no longer enough there.
- Hybrid invoices. They count if all the data to be reported is in the XML.
- Acceptance. An e-invoice under the standard then no longer needs your customer’s acceptance. A PDF still does.
- Domestic. Countries may keep allowing paper and PDF for invoices that carry no reporting obligation.
Official source: Directive (EU) 2025/516.
How to tell whether your PDF is an e-invoice
- Check whether there is an XML inside. Open the PDF in your PDF reader and look at the attachments. With Factur-X the attachment is called
factur-x.xml. If there is no XML, it is a plain PDF. - Check which profile it uses. MINIMUM is never enough. BASIC WL does not count in Germany. For France the law only names EN 16931 and EXTENDED-CTC-FR, so BASIC drops out there as well.
- Have it checked. The free Factur-X validator reads a PDF or XML, detects the profile and shows the first errors it finds. For an XRechnung there is the XRechnung validator.
Frequently asked questions
Is a PDF sent by email an e-invoice? Under the EU VAT Directive it is, until 1 July 2030, as long as your customer accepts it. Germany already dropped that broad meaning in 2025. In the sense of the European standard and in the countries with an obligation it is not: there only a structured invoice counts, an XML file that software reads without retyping.
Is a Factur-X or ZUGFeRD PDF an e-invoice? It can be, if the XML inside is complete and valid. In Germany ZUGFeRD counts from version 2.0.1, except the MINIMUM and BASIC WL profiles. In France the law names the EN 16931 and EXTENDED-CTC-FR profiles, and the invoice goes through a plateforme agréée. In Belgium no source mentions Factur-X; Peppol BIS is the default there.
Which part of a hybrid invoice counts: the PDF or the XML? In Germany the XML: if they differ, the XML prevails, and input VAT can only be deducted from the XML. In France the law and the official texts do not say which part prevails, but the standard requires the PDF to show all the data in the XML. So keep them identical.
Can I still send a PDF invoice in 2026? In the Netherlands yes, if your customer agrees, except to central government. In Belgium not between two businesses established in Belgium. Between German businesses until the end of 2026 with consent, for smaller businesses until the end of 2027. In France not as a large company or ETI invoicing a French business; SMEs may until 1 September 2027.
Is a digitally signed or scanned PDF an e-invoice? Not a structured one. A signature shows who sent the invoice and that it has not been changed, but it does not give it structure. Under the VAT Directive a signed PDF sent by email is an electronic invoice like any PDF; in the countries with an obligation it is not. A scan is an image of an invoice, and an image is nowhere a structured e-invoice.
I invoice a Belgian, German or French business from another country. Does it have to be an e-invoice? The obligations in those countries apply to businesses established there, so not to you as long as you have no establishment there. Your customer already receives e-invoices, though, and may ask for one. From 1 July 2030 you will need an e-invoice for invoices to businesses in other member states.
How do I check whether my PDF contains an e-invoice?
Open the attachments of the PDF and look for an XML file, with Factur-X factur-x.xml. Or let the free Factur-X validator read the PDF: it detects the profile and shows what fails.
What SealDoc does
SealDoc turns the invoice data from your own software into an e-invoice under EN 16931: a Factur-X, an XRechnung or a Peppol BIS invoice. Every invoice is checked against the schema and the validation rules of that format, and only an invoice that passes that check comes out. The validators on the site are free. Read how to e-invoice without replacing your accounting software.
In short
- A plain PDF is not a structured e-invoice. A Factur-X or ZUGFeRD can be one, if the XML inside is complete and valid.
- Under the EU VAT Directive, a PDF sent by email is still an electronic invoice until 1 July 2030, as long as your customer accepts it.
- Belgium already requires a structured invoice between businesses in the country. France has required it from large companies and ETIs since 1 September 2026, and from SMEs from 1 September 2027. Germany follows in 2027 and 2028, the Netherlands plans to follow on 1 July 2030.
- In Germany the XML is authoritative in a hybrid invoice. Keep the PDF and the XML identical.
- A PDF attached to an e-invoice is an attachment, not the invoice.
- From 1 July 2030, only a structured invoice counts for trade between member states.